Should the 49ers trade anyone on draft night?

Brandon Aiyuk

The soon-to-be fourth-year wideout has been the subject of trade talks this offseason, with several teams inquiring about Aiyuk’s availability, although the 49ers have been reluctant to engage in those conversations.

If the 49ers look to move Aiyuk this offseason, it would be at the NFL Draft, where they could fetch a potential first-rounder to improve their roster.

However, Aiyuk has two more years of team control, and should be the receiver that San Francisco looks to prioritize of their two star players when signing him to an extension next offseason.

Regardless, even if he isn’t in the future plans of the team, Aiyuk’s value should only improve with another strong season under his belt and a closer deadline to his extension, which would increase the package in return. He should be off the market this offseason.

Trey Lance

Recently, former third overall pick Trey Lance has also been involved in trade talks, with NFL Network’s Ian Rapoport reporting that the 49ers have fielded calls on their quarterback, with a trade potentially occurring at the draft.

A Lance trade would be the 49ers admitting their wrongs and looking to sell high, as his value diminishes this offseason if he loses the starting job to either Brock Purdy or Sam Darnold.

However, it would be irresponsible for the organization to do so, as the 49ers currently have uncertainty regarding their QB1 spot, as Brock Purdy’s recovery date is unknown until the three-month period arrives, while Sam Darnold has never taken a snap in a 49er uniform.

Moreover, the 49ers need at least three healthy quarterbacks to conduct their offseason program, and they’re currently one short, even with Lance on the roster. It seems like a poor decision to roll into the offseason with Darnold and two rookies/undrafted free agents, as it would take away from the depth that San Francisco emphasized when they added the former Panthers quarterback.

It also appears that the 49ers are only taking an exorbitant price for Lance, such as a first-round pick, which seems unfeasible to receive in return.

Elijah Mitchell

The 49ers have consistently faced injuries at the running back position. So, why would they engage in a potential trade for their current backup running back who has two years of team control left?

Mitchell has been injury-prone, but very effective in his time on the field, and his trade value is at a current high, as he’s under a cheap contract for the next two years, and would fill in well as a complementary piece in a rotation.

The 49ers would then open up reps for rookies Jordan Mason and Tyron-Davis Price, while likely targeting a rookie for their final running back spot.

With the trade, the 49ers would have good team control over their entire room and unload Mitchell at his point of highest value. I’ll buy this take.e