Pandemic show and tell: Texas second graders’ drawings and words reveal how COVID-19 touched their lives

As many children prepare to return to in-person school in the fall and alarming reports from across the U.S. and around the world point to a coming crisis in children’s mental health, some communities are getting out ahead of the grim forecasts. In Texas, teachers and mental health care providers are fortifying support systems, investing in kids’ resilience and expanding what works as they continue to fight for the future of the COVID-19 generation. This is the third story in a three-part series examining those efforts. Read the first story here. Read the second here.

Ashley Crandall’s second grade students didn’t like remote learning during the pandemic, and they hated wearing masks.

But they did like keeping their friends and family safe, and, as Crandall told them, the best way to do that was to keep masks up and to practice social distancing.

Ryu's drawing reads, “I liked playing with my friends at recess. But I hated wearing sweaty mask outside.” — Ryu’s drawing reads, “I liked playing with my friends at recess. But I hated wearing sweaty mask outside.”

“It’s bigger than just us,” Crandall reminded the kids when they complained about the masks. “We have to really think big picture about what’s happening in our community.”

Crandall did her best, largely successfully, to keep the scariest parts of the pandemic at bay in her classroom of 19 students, ages 7 to 9, at Democracy Prep at the Stewart Campus on the southeast side of San Antonio ISD, which was hit particularly hard by COVID-19.

“They’ve all been impacted in some way,” Crandall said, referring to lost jobs, family members who fell ill or died, and the general anxiety swirling through the community. “School provided a place for students to disconnect from fears that might have been placed on them.”

Because she could provide that safe place, fear, happiness and relief all showed up in artwork the students created for The 74, when they were asked to illustrate the best and most challenging parts of the year. The drawings conveyed two distinct messages:

First, the kids loved their friends, teacher and community, and had suffered during remote learning.

Second, the kids saw the value in safety protocols even though they hated the masks.

One girl even added a little second-grader shade to her response: “I like how people couldn’t get in my fase because of Covid.”

First: Kaylee’s drawing reads, “I like how people couldn’t get in my fase because of Covid, but I hated wearing a mask.” Last: Emanuel’s drawing reads, “I loved Ms. Crandall, but I didn’t like doing class on Zoom.”

The mental health effects of the pandemic went beyond fear, grief and loss related to the virus, and even the additional economic strain placed on families. Experts say the disruption and discomfort of safety protocols were stressful for kids.

“Kids are more sensitive. They’re not all rolling with the punches,” said school counselor Phyllis Fagell, author of the book “Middle School Matters.” It’s the job of the adults in their lives to keep stress from turning into anxiety by giving them tools to cope, she said.

Powerlessness — feeling that the pandemic and all of its protocols have been forced upon them — was part of the stress, Fagell said.

Having the power to help protect their loved ones and friends could actually help, if framed correctly, Fagell said. “We want them to focus on what they can control and what they care about.”

That’s a lesson that extends beyond the pandemic. Mask-wearing isn’t the last opportunity kids will have to embrace an inconvenience or disruption by seeing it as a contribution to their community.

Crandall’s success in helping alleviate her students’ anxiety meant that the kids didn’t feel the urgency of mask-wearing out of fear. She instead had to appeal to their shared values as a class — empathy for those who might have been fearful, civic duty to slow the spread of the virus and care for the health of others.

Fear, happiness, relief: Second graders’ art work shows their resilience during pandemic. The74Million

So instead of “the school is making me wear this uncomfortable mask,” Crandall would emphasize that choosing to wear a mask is a way to strengthen the community bond, because the kids knew they were sacrificing some comfort to keep one another safe.

The mind-shift worked: Student David Sutton said “keeping our community safe” was the best part of the year.

The 74Million.org is a nonprofit, nonpartisan media organization focused on America’s schools, education policy and 74 million children.

For mental health support related to COVID-19, call the state’s 24/7 toll-free support line at 833-986-1919. You can also reach a trained crisis counselor through the National Suicide Prevention Lifeline by calling 800-273-8255 or texting 741741. Read our mental health resource guide for more information.