“A slap in the face”: Charges dismissed in 45-year-old murder case

UNIVERSAL CITY, Texas – Forty-five years after Yolanda Herrera was murdered in Universal City, her family is once again without the closure they hoped for.

Kelly Lee Brower was arrested and charged with capital murder in August in connection with Herrera’s 1981 killing. But the Bexar County District Attorney’s Office has since dismissed the charge, saying the evidence did not meet the legal requirements to proceed.

For Herrera’s family, the decision has reopened painful memories.

“It’s like starting all over again. It reopened up all the old wounds,” Mary Gonzales, Herrera’s cousin, said. “Once again we have no closure.”

Herrera was 23 when she was murdered in 1981. The case remained unsolved for decades before investigators announced a major breakthrough this year.

Universal City police said in August that investigators had obtained a DNA match and that Brower had confessed to killing Herrera.

The announcement brought hope to Herrera’s family after decades of waiting.

“Thank God for the Rangers and Universal City Police Department,” Gonzales said at the time. “Now we can rest.”

But that hope changed when Gonzales said she was contacted Monday by the Bexar County DA’s Office and told the charges against Brower were being dismissed.

“A slap in the face. I literally got sick to my stomach,” Gonzales said.

Gonzales said she was told the DNA evidence was no longer sufficient because Brower has a brother who is in his 70s, raising questions about whether the DNA could belong to either sibling.

When asked whether she questioned how the DNA evidence could be insufficient, Gonzales said, “Absolutely, it’s DNA.”

She also said the DA’s Office gave her an explanation about Brower’s alleged confession that she found confusing.

“According to him, he confessed by the finger tap … whatever that means,” Gonzales said.

The arrest affidavit, however, contains verbal statements attributed to Brower. According to the affidavit, Brower told investigators, “I did do it” and “I killed her.” The affidavit also says detectives asked Brower whether he killed and had sex with Herrera, to which he allegedly responded, “yeah.”

The DA’s Office said the existing evidence did not meet the legal requirements needed to proceed with the case.

The office was asked to elaborate on the reason for dismissing the charges but had not provided additional details at the time of publication.

Brower has been released following the dismissal.

For Herrera’s family, the case is far from settled.

“I can’t say it on TV … shame on you,” Gonzales said when asked what she would say to the DA’s Office.

And when asked what she would say to her cousin, Gonzales responded: “It’s not over yet.”


READ MORE:

What do you feel about this?

Leave a Reply